Best Overall
Portta VD22P
Key details
- Inputs
- Composite, component, stereo RCA
- Storage
- USB, TF card, HDD/SSD up to 5 TB
- Preview Screen
- 5-inch HD LCD
- Recording Resolution
- 1080p at 60fps
A 5-inch screen and component inputs are the two features that separate the Portta VD22P from the cheaper recorders here. The screen lets you watch a tape without tying up the living-room TV, and the component input means a deck with YPbPr output can send its best signal. The converter records MP4 files at up to 1080p60 to a USB drive, TF card, portable hard drive, or SSD, with a stated ceiling of 5 TB.
We ended up treating it as the default for mixed collections. The larger screen is easier to read than the 3.5- and 4-inch panels on the other standalone units, and the file handling is straightforward: start a recording, stop it, and move the drive to a computer. Upscaling a VHS tape to 1080p does not add detail that was never there, but it produces a file that behaves well in modern editing software and on a phone. The brightness, contrast, and saturation controls are useful when a tape runs dark or washed out.
For everyone else, the combination of a big monitor, component support, and direct MP4 recording is what makes the VD22P worth its premium. The 5-inch screen is the part we missed when we went back to smaller units.
Pros
- 5-inch screen makes monitoring easy
- Component and composite inputs cover more decks
- Records MP4 to USB, TF, HDD, or SSD
- Brightness, contrast, and saturation controls
Cons
- No S-Video input
For a shelf of mixed VHS, Hi8, and camcorder tapes, the VD22P is the standalone recorder we recommend first: a big screen, component input, and MP4 files on a drive you already own.